Mike Burr - log

[scientific nonsense] Using standing sound waves to make...a thing

You could imagine a solid cylinder about 20 feet in diameter and "whatever" long. Maybe 20*k where 0.75 <= k <= 1.5 ... whatever. We'll say it's a cylinder (deftly crafted from computer-generated plans, with gussets and whatnot) about 20 feet high and 20 feet in diameter. You can lay it on its side if you want.

These speakers tightly (honeycomb?) line the inside, facing inwards and are all übercontrollable. You can write a function for each speaker that varies with time and takes all the other speaker data as input. Whatever... "arbitrarily controllable speakers". The driver diameter is up for consideration. Whatever you like—16" sub-woofers if you lack imagination.

With all this, and with whatever power is required, you maybe run some "sequences" that came out of a deep-learner that knows (well) fancy sound wave physics.

Or you could break out your calculus text book and spend a year designing and testing.

Things that are definitely possible:

Things that might be possible:

I feel like both 1) making standing waves of sound in a gigantic cylinder is hard but 2) hard in a regular, crackable way.

Other shapes?

What about all the vibration? I mean, this thing might cannot be made out of plywood because

  1. All that stuff will harmonize and introduce noise which would need to be modeled, which would be a nightmare.
  2. It needs to be strong because not only is it trying to shake itself apart, it's probably under a lot of extreme forces depending on how much you are pushing (meaning most of the structure itself is pulling)

I think designing a cylinder like this that needs to cary a (dynamic) load all more or less all directed outward. You could imagine a huge cylinder floating in space with a bunch of cars driving in side along the circle: That's a bridge! (sorta) The bigger point being, we have a lot of practice with bridges.

Seems to me like, especially if you're just throwing deep learning at it, having a few unobstructive sampling points would be good. (Depending) They shouldn't interfere with operation, they only really need to measure pressure. The sensor "arms" reaching inward (as I imagine it) only need to withstand the forces. "Wind" being one, but also (surely) crazy harmonics. If you are running some program from your deep-learner and you want to troubleshoot, having expected vs actual pressure "at these points" may help. Could also have a robotic probe: A cable running through the center that is robotically controlled and kept tight(sp).

Nice modeling potential. Depending on your budget and the quality vs size of speaker you can obtain, a small physical model of the jumbo one described would probably be a practical way to simulate.